Blog

Best D&D Initiative Tracker: 5 Free Apps Tested & Compared

I ran one fight in 5 free D&D initiative trackers. The best pick for in-person, online, new DMs and rules-heavy fights, plus a full comparison table.

Quill & Tankard

Five initiative trackers in the middle of the same fight: Improved Initiative, Quill & Tankard, the Initiative Tracker app, ShieldMaiden and D&D Beyond Maps.

I ran the same fight in 5 free initiative trackers to find out which one is best for a D&D table. D&D Beyond Maps, the official free tool, is the baseline, and I measured 4 dedicated trackers against it: Improved Initiative, Quill & Tankard, the Initiative Tracker app and ShieldMaiden. Each one handles turn order, HP, conditions and the player's view differently, and the best tracker depends on how you play.

What is the best D&D initiative tracker?

There isn't one best tracker for every table, so here is the best pick for each kind of game. These come from running the same fight, step by step, in every app.

  • Best for new DMs, and the baseline: D&D Beyond Maps. It has the least to track and learn. It has the least functionalities from a tracker standpoint but it's the easiest to pick up. Start here and switch to a dedicated tracker when you need concentration checks, death saves or a player link.

  • Best for online games: a tie between Improved Initiative and the Initiative Tracker app. Both give players a free live link to the turn order on their own phones or laptops. Improved Initiative has the bigger monster list and concentration checks. The Initiative Tracker app lets you choose what players see, and it tracks death saves.

  • Best for in-person tables: Quill & Tankard. Its initiative display puts the turn order on a TV at the table, with no HP numbers. It also tracks conditions and concentration, and it casts spells for you.

  • Best for rules-heavy fights: ShieldMaiden. It reminds you to roll concentration saves, shows the rules text for every condition, and tracks death saves. The screen takes some getting used to as there is a lot going on.

The full comparison table is at the end. Read on to see the details and nuances between each tracker app.

Five initiative trackers in the middle of the same fight: Improved Initiative, Quill & Tankard, the Initiative Tracker app, ShieldMaiden and D&D Beyond Maps.

How did I test the initiative trackers?

I ran one small fight, step by step, in every app. Each app had to be free, run in a browser and be built for D&D 5e (some support 2014, all support 2024).

The fight had two player characters, a fighter with 30 HP and a wizard with 20 HP, against two goblins and an owlbear. In each app I did the same ten things:

  • Set up the encounter: both PCs, two goblins and an owlbear.

  • Start combat and roll or type initiative.

  • Damage some combatants and heal some.

  • Have the wizard cast "Hold Person", so a goblin is "Paralyzed" and the wizard is concentrating.

  • Damage the wizard, to see if the app reminds me about a concentration save.

  • Add a wolf in the middle of the fight.

  • Drop a PC to 0 HP, to see if the app tracks death saves.

  • Open the player/spectator "public" view.

  • Assess the combat log and end the fight.

D&D Beyond Maps is the baseline. It's the official free tool, many DMs already have an account, and it stands in for the trackers built into virtual tabletops like Roll20, Foundry and Owlbear Rodeo. The other four are dedicated trackers and each section below starts with what it adds over D&D Beyond. Improved Initiative gets suggested on Reddit a lot, so it was an easy pick. I tested in November 2026. Apps change, so check the free tier before you commit to a specific tracker.

One more free tracker I didn't test: D&D Battle Tracker is open source and works offline.

What does D&D Beyond's free tracker give you?

The basics with the least to learn. D&D Beyond Maps tracks the turn order, HP and conditions on a map your players can see. It does less than the other four but it's the easiest to pick up. The Maps tracker and VTT is free with a free D&D Beyond account.

Setup takes the most steps. I had to create a campaign, add the characters to it on a separate page, open a map, and place the character tokens with the token browser. Then, I searched the token browser for the goblins and the owlbear. One big red button, Add All Tokens, puts everyone into the encounter. The search shows the 2024 monsters next to the older "Legacy" versions, and the encounter shows a difficulty rating.

D&D Beyond's Combat Encounter panel: two party members, Goblin x2 and an owlbear, Auto Initiative, difficulty High, and Start Combat.

Running the fight is simple. Initiative rolls automatically by default, and you can click a number to change it. "Next" moves the turn. Click HP, then heal or damage. It's pretty self explanatory and intuitive to pick up.

D&D Beyond's Initiative Order in round 2, with the token menu open on a goblin.

The rules help is thin. There's no easy way to cast "Hold Person" from the tracker so I set "Paralyzed" on the goblin by hand from its token. There's no concentration tracking for the wizard, no save reminder when it takes damage, and no death save tracking at 0 HP. Adding a wolf mid-fight is easy: search the token browser, place it, then add it to combat, and its initiative is set automatically.

D&D Beyond's Conditions dialog with "Paralyzed" switched on: no spell, save DC or concentration.

The below image shows the spectator view which is a public view of the map and initiative. Players see the whole map with the initiative order across the top. It shows no AC, HP or conditions, and names only appear when you hover over a portrait. With two goblins that share a picture, it's hard to tell them apart. The game log only shows the dice the DM rolled, not who took damage or what was cast. The fight is still there after a reload.

The D&D Beyond player view: portraits across the top of the map, with a name only on hover.
D&D Beyond's game log: two DM dice rolls and nothing else.

That's the baseline: turn order, HP and conditions by hand, on a map your players can see. If your game already runs on a virtual tabletop (VTT) like Roll20, Foundry or Owlbear Rodeo, its built-in tracker works a similar ways. A dedicated tracker makes the most sense at an in-person table, when your online game runs on voice chat without a map, or when you want the rules help the next four apps add. It's the added functionality that may make other initiative trackers appealing.

Is Improved Initiative still worth using?

Yes, especially for online games. Over D&D Beyond, it adds concentration checks, condition durations, and a player link with HP status and conditions, with no account for anyone. Improved Initiative is free, needs no account, and saves your fight in the browser.

Setup is quick for monsters. You search for them in the search bar and click to add, and the list includes the 2024 stat blocks, like the Goblin Warrior. Player characters can take longer because you fill in a full stat block form in the characters tab, but the full character stats is optional. You can just fill out HP, AC, and name to start. When you start the encounter, the app rolls initiative for you from each combatant's modifier, and you can reroll with advantage or disadvantage.

Improved Initiative in round 1: the active combatant's stat block on the left, and the initiative order with HP and AC in the middle.

HP changes are a little counterintuitive. You type a positive number to damage and a negative number to heal. Conditions are tags. You can give a tag a duration, and you can click it to read how the condition works.

Concentration is where Improved Initiative shines. Tag the wizard as "Concentrating", damage them, and the app shows the save DC with an automatic roll and pass and fail buttons. Adding a monster mid-fight asks for its initiative, so the order stays right.

Improved Initiative's concentration check after the wizard takes damage: DC 10, auto-roll 17, with fail and pass buttons.
Improved Initiative asks for the wolf's initiative when it joins mid-fight.

The player view is a public link that players open on their own devices, so nobody has to ask who's next. It shows PC HP as numbers, monsters as healthy or hurt, and conditions.

Improved Initiative's player view: the fighter at 0/30, monsters shown as healthy or hurt, and a "Paralyzed" tag on Goblin Warrior 1.

The gaps in features: there's no death save tracker, and the event log is a small bar at the bottom of the screen that you click to open. The page also shows an ad banner.

What does Quill & Tankard do differently?

It handles spells for you. Over D&D Beyond, it adds spells that set conditions and save DCs, concentration and save reminders, a full combat log, and a turn-order display for a TV. Quill & Tankard is free, needs no account, saves in the browser, and, full disclosure, it's the app I built. Right now, the app compendium only supports 5e 2024.

Setup has one extra step. You add PCs on the Roster page first, then the Add Combatants dialog adds the party and monsters together. It searches your roster and 332 creatures with 2024 stat blocks. You roll initiative for all the monsters at once and type in the players' rolls.

Quill & Tankard's Add Combatants dialog: both PCs selected, and a search box for the roster and 332 creatures.
Quill & Tankard in round 1: the current turn, Up Next, HP bars on each card, and the combat log beside the order.

To change HP, click the HP numbers, type the amount, and press Enter to damage or Shift+Enter to heal. You set a condition by typing its name. A lot of the other frequent actions are enabled by hotkeys as well. Conditions like "Paralyzed" or "Blinded" don't end on their own, so you have remove them manually yourself.

The Cast button is the big difference. The wizard casts "Hold Person", you pick the target, and the app adds "Paralyzed" with the WIS 13 save and marks the wizard as concentrating. When the wizard takes damage, it reminds you to roll a concentration save. On the goblin's turn, it reminds you to roll the goblin's save to end "Paralyzed". Initially, the spell casting bookkeeping is handled for you with tracking and reminders. This lessens the mental load for the DM.

Casting "Hold Person" in Quill & Tankard: pick the targets, and each one gets "Paralyzed" with a WIS 13 save.
After the cast, the wizard shows a "Hold Person" tag and the goblin shows "Paralyzed".
Quill & Tankard's concentration prompt: the wizard took damage, so roll a CON save at DC 10.
Quill & Tankard's reminder on the goblin's turn: roll a WIS save at DC 13 to end "Paralyzed".

The combat log records every turn, HP change, spell and save, and you can type quick notes into it. Finished fights go to past encounters.

Quill & Tankard's combat log: HP changes, a DOWNED tag, a spell cast, a passed save and every turn.

For players, the initiative display is built for a TV or second screen at the table. It shows the turn order, who's up next, conditions, concentration and who's down, but never HP. You can choose to reveal a monster's AC after it has lost HP three times, so players stop asking whether their attack hits. It also has a soundboard, NPC roster and item tracker in the same campaign.

The Quill & Tankard initiative display: Goblin Warrior has the current turn, the wizard concentrates on "Hold Person", and the fighter is DOWNED. No HP is shown.

The gaps in features here is that Quill & Tankard doesn't have a death saves tracker and doesn't allow for players to see the initiative order in a "public" view on their own mobile devices. This is mainly built for in-person tables as the "public" initiative order would be shown on a second monitor or screen.

Is the Initiative Tracker app good for online games?

Yes. Over D&D Beyond, it adds death saves, clearer HP buttons, and a player link where you choose exactly what players see. The Initiative Tracker app has a free plan that needs no account and saves in the browser.

Adding a player is a short form: name, class, HP and AC. Monsters are the weak spot. The free plan has no monster search, only a list of about 25 common creatures with 2014 stats, so most fights need custom creatures.

The Initiative Tracker app's sidebar: the party, and the free plan's short list of common creatures.
The Initiative Tracker app in round 1: the order with HP bars and AC, and the current turn marked.

The HP popover is the clearest of the five, with separate heal, damage and temp HP buttons. You add a condition by clicking a name, and you can set how long it lasts. Concentration is just another condition, though, and nothing reminds you to roll a save when the caster takes damage. A creature added mid-fight joins without initiative, so you type its number in yourself.

The Initiative Tracker app's HP popover with heal, damage and temp HP buttons.

Death saves are a strength. When a PC drops to 0 HP, a death save tracker appears on their row.

A death save tracker on the downed fighter's row in the Initiative Tracker app.

The player view is the most configurable of the five. The share view drawer lets you show or hide health bars, exact HP, AC, conditions and more, separately for players, friendly NPCs and hostile NPCs. Players open the link on their own devices. A session expires after 24 hours of inactivity, and a custom session name is a premium feature.

The Initiative Tracker app's share view options: health bars, health values, AC, conditions and visibility for each group.

The combat log is premium only. The subscription is £1.99 a month and adds cloud sync, the combat log and history, a D&D Beyond importer and no ads. The free plan allows one campaign and one party per device.

The Initiative Tracker app's combat log locked as a premium feature.

Is ShieldMaiden worth making an account for?

Yes, if you want the most rules help. Over D&D Beyond, it adds concentration reminders, rules text for every condition, death saves, a full combat log and damage meters. ShieldMaiden needs a free account to save fights and to share the initiative list with players. I tested its demo encounter, which works without one.

Setup is good. You add players in a short dialog, and you search monsters with a filter for 2014 or 2024 rules. A quantity box adds two goblins at once, with average HP or rolled HP.

ShieldMaiden's encounter builder: two players, two goblins and an owlbear, with a monster search and a difficulty rating.

The run screen has a learning curve. It took me a while to figure out that you change HP by picking a target in the middle panel, typing an amount, and clicking attack or heal. Once it clicks, it's a different system than all the other trackers: damage meters show how much damage each character has done.

Its rules help is strong. Each condition comes with its full rules text. Mark a caster as "Concentrating", and when they take damage, a pop-out tells you to roll to keep concentration. At 0 HP, death save skulls appear with save, fail and stabilize buttons.

ShieldMaiden's conditions panel: 15 conditions, with "Paralyzed" added to the goblin and its rules text open.
ShieldMaiden's run screen after the wizard takes damage: a CONCENTRATING pop-out, the log, and damage meters.
ShieldMaiden's death saves on the downed fighter, with save, fail and stabilize buttons.

Two limits. Adding a creature mid-fight is a quick-add form, where you type its initiative, AC and HP by hand instead of picking the full stat block. Conditions have no duration and no save reminder. The combat log and damage meters are free with an account.

ShieldMaiden's Add entity form: name, initiative, armor class and hit points typed by hand.

Improved Initiative or the Initiative Tracker app for online games?

They tie, so pick by what matters to you. Choose Improved Initiative if you want the full monster list and concentration checks. Choose the Initiative Tracker app if you want control over what players see and a death save tracker.

Do you NEED an initiative tracker app at all?

No. Pen and paper works and it's how I started. It just gets messy once conditions pile up.

I used to write each combatant's name and initiative in turn order. For HP, I added up damage until it reached the monster's HP number, instead of subtracting down to 0. I tracked conditions with abbreviations and crossed them out when they ended, but the page got cluttered and it was very error-prone. For stat blocks, I printed short versions of the monsters and NPCs I ran and read from the paper.

If you stay on paper, these free options help:

  • Initiative tents. Fold a card for each combatant, write the name on it, and hang the cards over your DM screen in turn order. DM David shares a free PDF of blank tents with spaces for AC and passive perception.

  • A whiteboard. Everyone at the table can read the order at once, and you wipe it clean after the fight.

  • A spreadsheet. A Google Sheets tab with names, initiative and HP is free, sorts in one click, and you can reuse it every session.

Printable tracker sets on Etsy and Gumroad usually cost a few dollars. An app earns its place when you run many monsters, spellcasters, or a table that keeps asking whose turn it is.

How do the free initiative trackers compare?

Here's how the five trackers compare on the things that matter most to a DM, with D&D Beyond Maps as the baseline. These are from my tests in November 2026.

D&D Beyond Maps (baseline)

Improved Initiative

Quill & Tankard

Initiative Tracker app

ShieldMaiden

Price

Free

Free. Patreon extras

Free

Free plan. £1.99/month adds the combat log and cloud sync

Free. Patreon tiers add extras

Account

Needed, with your characters in a campaign

Not needed

Not needed

Not needed

Needed to save fights and share the player list

Where your fight is saved

D&D Beyond's servers

Your browser

Your browser, with campaign export/import

Your browser; cloud sync is paid

Your account; the demo resets

Monster library

2024 and Legacy monsters

Full SRD, 2024 stat blocks

Full SRD, 2024 stat blocks

About 25 common creatures, 2014 stats

Searchable, 2014 or 2024 filter

Rules help mid-fight

Conditions set by hand only

Concentration check with DC; condition tags with durations

Spells set conditions and save DCs; concentration and save reminders

Death saves; condition durations

Concentration pop-out; condition rules text; death saves

What players see

Map with portraits; names on hover only

Live link: PC HP, monster healthy/hurt, conditions

TV display: order, conditions, concentration, DOWNED

Live link; you choose what shows

Public initiative list, with an account

Phone and tablet

Not tested

Desktop layout, stacked

Phone layout

Phone layout

Phone layout

After the fight

Dice rolls only

Event log in a bar at the bottom

Full log; last 20 fights kept

Log and history are paid

Log and damage meters

Beyond combat

Full virtual tabletop: maps, character sheets

Encounter and spell lists

Soundboard, NPC roster, item tracker

Party and custom creatures

Encounter builder, campaigns

Ads

None seen

Ad and Patreon banners

None

None seen; paid plan says "No ads, ever"

None seen in the demo

Which initiative tracker should you try first?

Start with the one that matches your table. For an in-person game with a TV or 2nd monitor, try Quill & Tankard. For online play, try Improved Initiative or the Initiative Tracker app. For rules-heavy fights, try ShieldMaiden. And if it's your first time behind the screen, start with D&D Beyond Maps and move up when you need more.

All five are free to start, and Quill & Tankard will stay free for everything shown here. If you want to see how it runs your next fight, open the combat tracker. There's also a step-by-step guide to the Quill & Tankard initiative tracker.